2B Christianity - Section A: Expressions of religious identity — AQA A-Level Religious Studies
2B Christianity - Section A: Expressions of religious identity explained
2B Christianity - Section A: Expressions of religious identity covers 3 specification points, including The significance of infant baptism in… and Differing practices associated with Holy….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
Baptism: the significance of infant baptism in Christianity with particular reference to the Catholic and Baptist traditions; arguments in favour of and against infant baptism.
Infant baptism is the rite in which water is applied to a baby, and its significance differs between traditions. In the Catholic tradition baptism is a sacrament that removes original sin, incorporates the child into the Church and is administered to infants on the basis of the faith of the Church and parents, who promise to raise the child in the faith. In the Baptist tradition baptism is administered only to those who can make a personal profession of faith, so infants are not baptised; a dedication or thanksgiving may be held instead. Arguments in favour of infant baptism include the practice of household baptism in the New Testament, the belief that grace is given before conscious faith, and the pastoral value of welcoming a child into the community.
Holy Communion: differing practices associated with Holy Communion, and differing understandings of Holy Communion and its importance, in the Catholic and Baptist Churches; different Christian understandings of the significance of Jesus’ actions at the last supper, Luke 22:17–20.
Holy Communion is celebrated differently across traditions. In the Catholic Church the Mass is understood as a sacrament in which the bread and wine become the body and blood of Christ, and it is central to Catholic worship and grace. In the Baptist Church the Lord's Supper is a memorial and an act of obedience, celebrated less frequently and understood as a symbol rather than a sacrament conveying grace. Luke 22:17–20 records Jesus taking the cup, giving thanks, sharing bread and cup with his disciples and interpreting them as his body given and blood poured out, and commanding his followers to do this in remembrance of him. Different Christians understand these actions as a memorial, as a sacrifice, as a means of grace or as a symbolic act, and this shapes how important Communion is seen to be.
The mission of the Church: developments in Christian ideas of ‘mission’ from the early 20th century to today.
Mission means the sending of the Church to share and embody the gospel. From the early twentieth century, the modern ecumenical movement reshaped the idea: the 1910 Edinburgh conference coordinated Protestant missionary societies, and the International Missionary Council (formed 1921) linked mission agencies before merging into the World Council of Churches in 1961. The WCC then produced mission statements, including 'Mission and Evangelism: An Ecumenical Affirmation' (1982), which set evangelism within justice, liberation and dialogue. Later WCC texts, such as 'Together Towards Life' (2013), stressed mission from the margins and care for creation. Meanwhile the Lausanne Movement (1974) emphasised evangelism and church planting, and Roman Catholic teaching shifted at the Second Vatican Council (1962–65), whose decree Ad Gentes tied mission to the Church's universal calling.
Your focus
- Explain the significance of infant baptism in the Catholic tradition.
- Explain why the Baptist tradition does not baptise infants.
- Give arguments in favour of and against infant baptism.
Show all 9 objectives
- Describe differing practices associated with Holy Communion in the Catholic and Baptist Churches.
- Explain differing understandings of Holy Communion and its importance.
- Explain different Christian understandings of the significance of Jesus' actions at the last supper in Luke 22:17–20.
- Identify the main twentieth- and twenty-first-century documents and bodies shaping Christian ideas of mission.
- Explain how missio Dei reframes the Church's role in mission.
- Compare conciliar, evangelical and Catholic approaches to mission.
2B Christianity - Section A: Expressions of religious identity exam tips
Marking Points
- Identifies that the Catholic tradition treats baptism as a sacrament that removes original sin and incorporates the infant into the Church.
- Explains that the Baptist tradition reserves baptism for believers who can make a personal profession of faith, so infants are not baptised.
- States that Catholic infant baptism relies on the faith of the Church and parents, who promise to raise the child in the faith.
- Outlines an argument in favour of infant baptism, such as the New Testament practice of household baptism or the belief that grace is given before conscious faith.
- Outlines an argument against infant baptism, such as the need for personal repentance and faith or the view that baptism should follow a believer's own decision.
- Identifies that the Catholic Church understands Holy Communion as a sacrament in which the bread and wine become the body and blood of Christ.
- Explains that the Baptist Church understands the Lord's Supper as a memorial and act of obedience rather than a sacrament conveying grace.
- Describes differing practices, such as frequency of celebration and who may receive Communion.
- Explains that Luke 22:17–20 records Jesus giving thanks, sharing bread and cup, and commanding his followers to do this in remembrance of him.
- Outlines different Christian understandings of the significance of Jesus' actions at the last supper, such as memorial, sacrifice or means of grace.
- Identifies the International Missionary Council as a coordinating body formed in 1921 that merged into the World Council of Churches in 1961.
- Attributes 'Mission and Evangelism: An Ecumenical Affirmation' (1982) to the World Council of Churches rather than to the International Missionary Council.
- Explains that missio Dei thinking presents mission as God's own activity in which the Church participates.
- Contrasts the WCC emphasis on justice, dialogue and the margins with the Lausanne Movement's emphasis on evangelism and church planting.
- Connects the Second Vatican Council's decree Ad Gentes to a renewed Catholic understanding of the Church's missionary calling.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Read the question stem carefully to see whether it asks about practice, significance or arguments for and against.
- 💡Use the terms 'sacrament', 'original sin' and 'believers' baptism' accurately.
- 💡When asked for arguments, give both a reason in favour and a reason against, each with a brief explanation.
- 💡Use the correct terms: 'Mass', 'sacrament', 'transubstantiation', 'memorial' and 'Lord's Supper'.
- 💡Refer explicitly to Luke 22:17–20 when discussing Jesus' actions at the last supper.
- 💡Compare the two traditions directly rather than describing them separately.
- 💡Learn the key dates and which body issued each document, because attribution is a frequent discriminator in multiple-choice items.
- 💡Distinguish conciliar (WCC) from evangelical (Lausanne) and Catholic (Vatican II) strands when comparing ideas of mission.
- 💡Use the phrase missio Dei precisely, linking it to God's initiative rather than to human strategy.
- 💡Check the issuing body before selecting an option that names the IMC for post-1961 documents.
Common Mistakes
- Assumes that all Christians baptise infants; correct this by noting that the Baptist tradition baptises only those who profess faith personally.
- Treats infant baptism as merely a naming ceremony; correct this by explaining its sacramental significance in the Catholic tradition.
- Ignores the arguments against infant baptism; correct this by giving at least one reason, such as the need for personal faith.
- Confuses the Baptist tradition with the Catholic tradition; correct this by keeping the two positions distinct.
- Treats all Christian celebrations of Communion as identical; correct this by distinguishing Catholic sacramental understanding from Baptist memorial understanding.
- Describes the Baptist Lord's Supper as conveying grace in the same way as the Catholic Mass; correct this by noting the Baptist emphasis on symbol and obedience.
- Ignores the Luke 22:17–20 passage; correct this by referring to Jesus' actions and command to remember him.
- Assumes Communion has the same importance in every tradition; correct this by explaining that it is central in Catholic worship but less frequent and symbolic in Baptist practice.
- Attributes the 1982 ecumenical affirmation on mission and evangelism to the International Missionary Council; credit the World Council of Churches, since the IMC had merged into the WCC in 1961.
- Treats mission as identical to evangelism alone; recognise that modern statements widen mission to include justice, dialogue and care for creation.
- Dates the Second Vatican Council to the early twentieth century; place it in 1962–65 as a mid-century development.
- Presents missio Dei as a Church programme; describe it as God's prior activity in which the Church participates.