Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity, gender and sexuality — AQA A-Level Religious Studies

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity, gender and sexuality explained

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity, gender and sexuality covers 4 specification points, including The development of Biblical criticism,… and Debates about female ordination in the Church….

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Historical and social factors that have influenced developments in Christian thinking about these issues including: the development of Biblical criticism, especially in the 19th century, and the resulting freedom to challenge traditional readings of passages such as 1 Tim 2:8-15; the changing roles of men and women in society outside of religion; the rights given to women by secular governments.

    This topic examines three historical and social factors shaping Christian thinking about gender and sexuality. First, nineteenth-century Biblical criticism applied historical and literary methods to scripture, giving scholars freedom to question traditional readings of passages such as 1 Timothy 2:8-15, which had been used to restrict women's roles. Second, changing roles of men and women outside religion, including women's entry into education and paid work and the two World Wars, prompted churches to reconsider women's ministry. Third, rights granted to women by secular governments, such as suffrage and anti-discrimination and equality legislation, created pressure on churches to review their practice. Learn each factor, how it operated, and how it influenced Christian debate. Distinguish the factor from its effect on theology.

    Debates about female ordination in the Church of England up to and after 1994, the continuing debate today.

    The Church of England debated women's ordination through the twentieth century. The 1975 General Synod received the report 'The Ordination of Women to the Priesthood', and in 1987 the Synod voted in principle to admit women to the priesthood. In November 1992 the General Synod voted to ordain women as priests, and the Priests (Ordination of Women) Measure 1993 gave legal effect; the first ordinations took place in 1994. Some opponents left for the Roman Catholic Church or joined the Traditional Anglican Communion, and provision was made for parishes and clergy who could not accept the change. Debate continued over women bishops: the General Synod rejected legislation in 2012, then approved it in 2014, and the first woman bishop, Libby Lane, was consecrated in January 2015.

    A comparison of the significant ideas of Daphne Hampson and Rosemary Radford Ruether about the patriarchal nature of Christianity including Hampson’s view that Christianity is irredeemably sexist and Ruether’s ideas about the androgynous Christ and her view that the female nature is more Christlike than the male.

    Compare two feminist theologians on Christianity's patriarchy. Hampson concludes that Christianity is irredeemably sexist: because its central symbols and structures are male-centred, she judges that it cannot be reformed from within and that women should move beyond it, grounding her ethics in a post-Christian, autonomy-based view. Ruether stays within a prophetic Christian framework: she critiques patriarchal imagery and calls for an androgynous Christ in which neither maleness nor femaleness is essential to Christ's significance, and she argues that female nature can be seen as more Christlike than the male because women's experience of suffering and nurturing mirrors Christ's redemptive pattern. Compare their diagnoses of patriarchy, their remedies (abandonment versus reform), and their use of Christology.

    Different Christian views about celibacy, marriage, homosexuality and transgender issues.

    This topic asks you to map the range of Christian positions, not to settle them. For celibacy, distinguish those who treat it as a Spirit-given vocation (often citing Paul's preference for the single life and the celibate priesthood) from those who see lifelong singleness as a fallback to marriage. For marriage, contrast sacramental views that treat it as a permanent covenant between a man and a woman with views stressing companionship and mutual love. On homosexuality, range from conservative readings of scriptural texts that reserve sexual intimacy for heterosexual marriage, through pastoral acceptance of same-sex relationships, to churches that bless or solemnise them. On transgender issues, contrast communities that affirm gender transition with those that hold a complementarian or creation-order view.

    Your focus

    1. Identify the three historical and social factors named in the statement.
    2. Explain how one factor influenced a development in Christian thinking about gender.
    3. Distinguish a social or historical cause from its effect on Christian theology.
    Show all 12 objectives
    1. Sequence the key events in the Church of England's debate on female ordination.
    2. Explain the arguments used for and against ordaining women.
    3. Assess how the debate has continued after 1994, including women bishops.
    4. Explain Hampson's claim that Christianity is irredeemably sexist.
    5. Explain Ruether's ideas of the androgynous Christ and the Christlikeness of female nature.
    6. Compare the two thinkers' diagnoses and remedies for patriarchy and reach a supported judgement.
    7. Outline at least two Christian views on each of the four issues
    8. Explain the reasoning behind each view
    9. Attribute views to named traditions or thinkers

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity, gender and sexuality exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Explains how nineteenth-century Biblical criticism gave scholars methods to question traditional readings of passages such as 1 Timothy 2:8-15.
    • Describes how changing roles of men and women in society outside religion, such as women's education and employment, influenced Christian thinking.
    • Identifies rights granted to women by secular governments, such as suffrage and equality legislation, as a factor shaping church debate.
    • Links a named factor to a specific change in Christian thinking, distinguishing the social cause from its theological effect.
    • Distinguishes the 1992 General Synod vote in favour of ordaining women as priests from the first ordinations that took place in 1994.
    • Identifies the Priests (Ordination of Women) Measure 1993 as the legislation giving legal effect to the change.
    • Explains that provision was made for parishes and clergy unable to accept women's ordination.
    • Connects the later debate about women bishops to the 2014 approval and the 2015 consecration of Libby Lane.
    • Contrasts arguments from Galatians 3:28 with arguments from apostolic precedent and selected Pauline texts.
    • States Hampson's view that Christianity is irredeemably sexist and explains why she regards its male-centred symbolism as beyond reform.
    • Explains Ruether's idea of the androgynous Christ, in which Christ's significance is not tied to maleness.
    • Explains Ruether's view that female nature is more Christlike than the male, linking it to her account of suffering and redemptive love.
    • Compares the two thinkers' remedies, contrasting Hampson's move beyond Christianity with Ruether's reforming, prophetic critique from within.
    • Compares how each uses Christology and the doctrine of God to diagnose patriarchy.
    • Reaches a supported judgement about which analysis of patriarchy is more persuasive and why.
    • Identifies celibacy as a vocation valued by some traditions and as a lesser calling by others
    • Distinguishes sacramental covenant views of marriage from companionship-centred views
    • Contrasts conservative, pastoral and affirming Christian positions on homosexuality
    • Explains transgender debates by reference to creation-order and affirmation arguments
    • Attributes each position to a named tradition or thinker rather than a vague 'Christians'
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Name each of the three factors explicitly so the examiner can see full coverage.
    • 💡Give a concrete example for each factor, such as a specific right granted to women or a named critical method.
    • 💡Explain the causal link between the factor and the change in Christian thinking rather than listing factors.
    • 💡Keep examples within the modern period the factors describe, and avoid drifting into unrelated issues.
    • 💡Keep the sequence of dates clear: 1992 vote, 1993 Measure, 1994 first ordinations, 2014 approval for women bishops, 2015 first woman bishop.
    • 💡Present arguments for and against ordination with the scriptural and traditional warrants attached to each.
    • 💡Use precise terms such as 'priest', 'bishop' and 'General Synod' rather than vague references to 'the Church'.
    • 💡Show awareness that the debate continues, citing contemporary concerns rather than treating 1994 as an endpoint.
    • 💡Structure the answer around points of comparison rather than two separate summaries.
    • 💡Use each thinker's own key terms, such as irredeemably sexist and androgynous Christ, accurately.
    • 💡Support the final judgement with reasons drawn from the comparison, not assertion.
    • 💡Learn two named traditions per issue so you can contrast them quickly
    • 💡Link each view to a reason, such as scriptural authority or natural law
    • 💡Read the question stem carefully to see whether it asks for views, reasons or evaluation
    Common Mistakes
    • Confuses the factor with its effect; state the historical or social cause separately from the change in Christian thinking it produced.
    • Treats Biblical criticism as rejecting the Bible outright; recognise it as a method of historical and literary study that opened debate.
    • Omits the secular-government factor; include rights such as suffrage and equality legislation as a distinct influence.
    • Restricts the discussion to one factor; address Biblical criticism, changing social roles and secular rights as three separate influences.
    • States that the General Synod voted to ordain women in 1994; separate the 1992 vote and 1993 Measure from the 1994 first ordinations.
    • Treats the debate as settled in 1994; recognise that the women bishops debate continued to 2014–15 and arguments persist today.
    • Assumes all opponents left the Church of England; note that provision was made for those who remained.
    • Cites Galatians 3:28 without explaining how it supports equality in ordination; link the text to the argument.
    • Treats both thinkers as holding identical positions; correct this by contrasting Hampson's irredeemability claim with Ruether's reforming stance.
    • Attributes the androgynous Christ idea to Hampson; correct this by assigning it to Ruether.
    • Reduces Ruether's claim about female nature to biological essentialism; correct this by explaining it in terms of Christlike suffering and love.
    • Describes Hampson as seeking internal reform of the Church; correct this by stating her conclusion that Christianity cannot be redeemed from its sexism.
    • Treats all Christians as holding one view on sexuality; correct this by naming at least two contrasting traditions
    • Confuses celibacy with the rejection of all relationships; correct this by explaining it as abstaining from sexual activity, often for religious service
    • Asserts a view without giving its reasoning; correct this by supplying the scriptural or theological basis