Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity and the challenge of secularisation — AQA A-Level Religious Studies

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity and the challenge of secularisation explained

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity and the challenge of secularisation covers 5 specification points, including The view that religion is irrational.

    Read the full explanation

    and The value of wealth and possessions.. Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    This topic may be studied with exclusive reference to the British context. The challenge of secularisation including the replacement of religion as the source of truth and moral values; relegation of religion to the personal sphere; the rise of militant atheism: the view that religion is irrational.

    Secularisation is the decline of religion's public influence, and this topic may be studied with exclusive reference to the British context. Three challenges matter. First, religion loses its place as the source of truth and moral values: science, law and secular ethics become the default authorities, so appeals to scripture or church teaching carry less public weight. Second, religion is relegated to the personal sphere: belief becomes a private lifestyle choice rather than a shared public framework, and church attendance and influence on law decline. Third, militant atheism argues that religion is irrational, treating faith as belief without evidence and incompatible with reason and science.

    Responses to materialistic secular values: the value of wealth and possessions.

    This topic asks how Christian thought answers a secular culture that treats wealth and possessions as the main measure of a good life. A materialistic outlook ties wellbeing to what a person owns, buys and displays, and treats acquisition as the goal of work. Christian responses draw on teaching that the person is worth more than their property, that possessions carry responsibility toward others, and that attachment to goods can compete with devotion to God. Learners should be able to explain why a consumer culture is seen as a challenge to Christian values, and how Christians argue wealth can be used well rather than simply rejected. A useful method is to contrast two claims: the secular claim that more possessions means more flourishing, and the Christian claim that generosity, stewardship and inner disposition matter more than accumulation.

    McGrath’s defence of Christianity in ‘The Dawkins delusion’.

    This topic concerns Alister McGrath's response to Richard Dawkins in 'The Dawkins Delusion?', co-written with Joanna Collicutt McGrath. The book answers the arguments of Dawkins' 'The God Delusion', which presents religious belief as irrational and harmful. McGrath defends Christianity by questioning whether the scientific method is the only route to knowledge, by arguing that science and religious faith can be held together, and by challenging the claim that religion is inherently a cause of violence. He also argues that Dawkins' portrayal of religion is a simplification that ignores the diversity of Christian belief and practice. Learners should be able to state McGrath's main lines of defence and explain why he thinks the secular critique misrepresents Christianity, rather than merely asserting that he disagrees with Dawkins.

    Emergence of new forms of expression, such as Fresh Expressions and the House Church movement.

    This topic sits within the study of Christianity and the challenge of secularisation. Learners need to explain why new forms of Christian expression have emerged in Britain and what characterises them. Fresh Expressions describes initiatives, often backed by established denominations, that plant church in settings outside traditional buildings and Sunday patterns, for example a congregation meeting in a café, a school or a community hall, or a 'messy church' gathering aimed at families. The House Church movement describes small groups meeting in homes for worship, Bible study and mutual support, often valuing informality and shared leadership. A strong answer links both to secularisation: declining attendance and cultural marginalisation prompt Christians to experiment with new structures and styles of communication.

    Emphasis on the social relevance of Christianity including liberationist approaches as supporting the poor and defending the oppressed.

    Within the study of Christianity and secularisation, learners examine how Christians stress the social relevance of their faith. This means showing that Christianity speaks to public life, not only to private belief. Liberationist approaches, associated with liberation theology, read the gospel as a mandate to side with the poor and to defend the oppressed against unjust structures. Key ideas include a preferential option for the poor, reading scripture through the experience of the marginalised, and practical action for justice. In a secularising society, this emphasis can present Christianity as socially engaged and relevant. Candidates should explain what liberationist approaches claim, how they support the poor and defend the oppressed, and why this emphasis matters for the debate about secularisation.

    Your focus

    1. Define secularisation and distinguish it from the loss of personal belief.
    2. Explain the three named challenges to religion in the British context.
    3. Illustrate each challenge with a British example.
    Show all 15 objectives
    1. Explain what materialistic secular values claim about wealth and possessions.
    2. Describe at least two Christian responses to those values.
    3. Contrast secular and Christian views of the value of possessions.
    4. State the main arguments McGrath uses to defend Christianity.
    5. Explain how McGrath responds to Dawkins' critique of religion.
    6. Assess the strength of McGrath's defence against secular criticism.
    7. Describe what Fresh Expressions are and give an example of their setting.
    8. Describe the House Church movement and its typical features.
    9. Explain how both forms respond to the challenge of secularisation in Britain.
    10. Explain what is meant by the social relevance of Christianity.
    11. Describe how liberationist approaches support the poor and defend the oppressed.
    12. Explain why an emphasis on social relevance matters in the context of secularisation.

    2B Christianity - Section A: Christianity and the challenge of secularisation exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Defines secularisation as the decline of religion's public and social influence rather than the disappearance of personal belief.
    • Explains the replacement of religion as the source of truth and moral values, showing how science, law or secular ethics take that role.
    • Explains the relegation of religion to the personal sphere, showing belief becoming a private choice rather than a public framework.
    • Explains the rise of militant atheism and its claim that religion is irrational, contrasting faith with evidence-based reasoning.
    • Explains that materialistic secular values measure human worth and success largely by wealth and possessions.
    • Identifies Christian teaching that a person's value is not determined by what they own.
    • Explains the idea of stewardship, where possessions are held in trust and used responsibly for others.
    • Contrasts consumer acquisition as an end in itself with Christian emphasis on generosity and detachment.
    • Recognises that Christian responses may affirm wealth as a resource while warning against attachment to it.
    • Explains that McGrath challenges the claim that science is the only reliable source of knowledge.
    • Describes McGrath's argument that scientific enquiry and Christian faith can coexist rather than conflict.
    • Identifies McGrath's response to the charge that religion is inherently violent or harmful.
    • Explains that McGrath accuses Dawkins of oversimplifying and misrepresenting religious belief.
    • Shows how McGrath defends the rationality of Christian belief against the charge of delusion.
    • Identifies Fresh Expressions as new initiatives, often supported by established denominations, that form Christian communities outside traditional church buildings and patterns.
    • Identifies the House Church movement as small groups meeting in homes for worship, study and mutual support, often with informal and shared leadership.
    • Explains that both forms respond to secularisation by reaching people who do not attend traditional churches.
    • Distinguishes the two forms by noting that Fresh Expressions are often denominationally sponsored while house churches are typically small and locally organised.
    • Links the emergence of new forms to declining attendance and the reduced cultural influence of organised religion in Britain.
    • Explains that emphasising social relevance presents Christianity as concerned with public life and justice, not only private belief.
    • Describes liberationist approaches as reading the gospel through the experience of the poor and marginalised.
    • Identifies the preferential option for the poor as a central liberationist idea.
    • Explains that liberationist approaches defend the oppressed by challenging unjust social and economic structures.
    • Links the emphasis on social relevance to the challenge of secularisation by showing how it presents Christianity as engaged and meaningful in society.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Define secularisation precisely before applying the three challenges.
    • 💡Keep each challenge distinct so the answer covers all three clauses of the topic.
    • 💡Use a British example to show the challenge operating in context rather than in the abstract.
    • 💡Define materialistic secular values briefly before contrasting them with Christian teaching.
    • 💡Use one concrete example, such as a person choosing generous giving over display, to show the contrast.
    • 💡Link each Christian response back to the challenge it answers rather than listing teachings in isolation.
    • 💡Name the book and its target clearly so the examiner sees you know the context.
    • 💡Give at least two distinct lines of McGrath's defence rather than one general claim.
    • 💡Explain the reasoning behind each defence, not just that McGrath disagrees with Dawkins.
    • 💡Define each term briefly before explaining why it emerged, so the examiner sees secure knowledge.
    • 💡Use one concrete example of a setting, such as a café or a home, to anchor each form.
    • 💡Keep the focus on the challenge of secularisation, since that is the section being assessed.
    • 💡Use the precise term 'preferential option for the poor' to show secure knowledge.
    • 💡Give one concrete example of action for justice, such as advocacy for the poor, to illustrate the claim.
    • 💡Tie the point back to secularisation so the answer stays within the section being assessed.
    Common Mistakes
    • Equates secularisation with the end of all religious belief; distinguish declining public influence from continuing private belief.
    • Describes the three challenges without distinguishing them; separate truth and morality, the personal sphere, and militant atheism as distinct claims.
    • Offers a general claim without a British illustration; anchor each challenge in the British context the topic permits.
    • Treats Christianity as uniformly rejecting all wealth; correct this by noting that the tradition often stresses responsible use rather than blanket condemnation.
    • Confuses materialism as a philosophical claim about matter with materialistic values as a lifestyle focused on possessions; keep the two meanings distinct.
    • Asserts that Christian teaching simply endorses prosperity; correct this by explaining the warnings about attachment and the duty of generosity.
    • Ignores the secular side of the debate; state the materialistic value being challenged before giving the Christian response.
    • Attributes the argument of 'The God Delusion' to McGrath; keep Dawkins as the critic and McGrath as the defender.
    • Treats McGrath as rejecting science outright; correct this by explaining that he argues science and faith can be compatible.
    • Summarises the book as simple abuse of Dawkins; correct this by identifying the specific arguments McGrath makes.
    • Forgets that the book was co-written with Joanna Collicutt McGrath; name the authorship accurately.
    • Treats Fresh Expressions and the House Church movement as identical; distinguish their sponsorship, size and setting.
    • Assumes new forms of expression are simply changes in music or style; explain that they involve new structures and settings for being church.
    • Ignores the link to secularisation; connect each new form to the challenge of declining attendance or cultural marginalisation.
    • Presents every new form as a rejection of tradition; note that many Fresh Expressions are backed by established denominations.
    • Treats liberationist approaches as purely political activism; explain their grounding in Christian scripture and belief.
    • Confuses the preferential option for the poor with favouritism; clarify that it means a special concern for those who are disadvantaged.
    • Describes social relevance only in general terms; specify how liberationist approaches support the poor and defend the oppressed.
    • Omits the connection to secularisation; show why this emphasis matters in a society where organised religion is declining.