Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    2B Christianity - Section B: The dialogue between Christianity and philosophy — AQA A-Level Religious Studies

    2B Christianity - Section B: The dialogue between Christianity and philosophy explained

    2B Christianity - Section B: The dialogue between Christianity and philosophy covers 11 specification points, including God and self, death and the afterlife.

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    God

    This row asks you to examine the concept of God as it arises in the dialogue between Christianity and philosophy. A strong answer identifies the attributes at stake — omnipotence, omniscience, omnibenevolence, eternity and simplicity — and tests them against philosophical objections, then shows how Christian thought responds. For example, the problem of evil presses the coherence of omnipotence with omnibenevolence, while the Euthyphro dilemma asks whether God commands the good because it is good or makes it good by commanding it. Weigh whether responses such as divine command theory, process thought or a defence of analogy preserve the classical concept or revise it. Reach a justified judgement rather than listing views.

    self, death and the afterlife

    This row asks you to explore Christian teaching on the self, death and the afterlife and to test it against philosophical critique. Cover the nature of the self (body and soul, or a unified person), the significance of death, and claims about resurrection, judgement, heaven and hell. Philosophical dialogue includes dualism versus materialism, the coherence of survival after bodily death, and objections that an eternal punishment or reward is unjust. Show how Christian thinkers respond — for example through bodily resurrection rather than mere soul-survival — and weigh whether these responses are persuasive. Build a reasoned judgement about which account of the self and destiny is most defensible.

    sources of wisdom and authority

    This topic asks you to examine what Christians treat as sources of wisdom and authority and how those sources function when Christian belief meets philosophical argument. Identify the sources: scripture, tradition, the magisterium in some traditions, reason, religious experience and the example of Christ. Then explain how each is used to justify or challenge a philosophical claim, for example how a Christian might appeal to scripture or to natural reason when responding to the problem of evil or to arguments for God's existence. Assess strengths and limits: reason may be shared with non-believers, while appeals to revelation may not persuade them. Reach a reasoned judgement about which sources carry most weight and why.

    religious experience

    Here you examine religious experience as a point of contact and tension between Christianity and philosophy. Set out what counts as a religious experience, such as mystical union, numinous awareness of the holy, or a sense of being addressed by God, and explain how Christians appeal to such experience as evidence or support for belief. Then bring philosophical scrutiny to bear: questions about whether experiences can be verified, whether they are interpreted through prior beliefs, whether they are reliable, and whether they can ground claims about God. Weigh the evidential value of experience against these objections, consider responses such as arguing that experience is self-authenticating or that it coheres with doctrine, and reach a justified judgement about how far religious experience supports Christian belief in dialogue with philosophy.

    the relationship between scientific and religious discourses

    This topic asks you to analyse how scientific discourse and religious discourse relate within Christian thought. Treat each as a discourse: a structured way of speaking, reasoning and justifying claims, with its own methods, authorities and purposes. Scientific discourse typically proceeds by empirical observation, testable hypothesis and peer review; religious discourse typically proceeds by revelation, scripture, tradition and reasoned reflection on experience. Explore the possible relationships: conflict, where each makes rival claims about origins or human nature; independence, where each answers different questions and so does not compete; and dialogue or integration, where findings inform theological reflection and theology frames the questions science pursues.

    the truth claims of other religions

    This topic asks you to examine how Christians assess the truth claims of other religions and how that assessment bears on philosophical questions. Consider exclusivism, inclusivism and pluralism as positions a Christian might hold, and explain the reasoning behind each: exclusivists hold that salvation is through Christ alone, inclusivists allow that sincere followers of other faiths may be saved through Christ without knowing it, and pluralists hold that many religions offer valid paths to the divine. Assess each position's strengths and difficulties, for example whether pluralism undermines Christian truth claims or whether exclusivism is consistent with a loving God. Reach a reasoned judgement about which position is most defensible.

    miracles. The following issues, and the impact of the discussion on religious belief past and present, should be considered:

    This row asks you to weigh the philosophical issues raised by miracle claims and then trace how that debate has shaped Christian belief across time and today. Treat the issues as a set of connected problems: what counts as a miracle (a violation of natural law, an event with religious significance, or an unexpected event attributed to God), whether testimony can reliably establish one, whether evidence is ever strong enough, and how a benevolent, omnipotent God relates to suffering if miracles are selective. David Hume's argument against testimony is central, alongside defences such as Swinburne's principles of testimony and credulity. Then assess impact: past debates fed into canonisation procedures and apologetics; present debates shape how Christians defend providence, answer sceptics and interpret answered prayer.

    How far the belief is reasonable – that is based on reason and/or consistent with reason.

    This row asks you to judge how far a Christian belief can be called reasonable, where reasonable means either grounded in reason or at least not contradicted by it. Separate the two tests: a belief is based on reason when arguments support it, and consistent with reason when it does not conflict with what reason establishes. Apply this to a specific belief, such as belief in God or in miracles. Consider rational defences: cosmological and teleological arguments, natural theology, and the coherence of theism. Consider challenges: the problem of evil, the hiddenness of God, and reliance on faith or revelation that appears to bypass reason. Weigh whether faith and reason are complementary or in tension, and reach a judgement on how far the belief survives rational scrutiny.

    How meaningful the statements of faith are, and for whom.

    This criterion asks you to weigh how meaningful Christian statements of faith are and to identify for whom they carry meaning. A statement of faith is a formulated confession, such as a creed or a doctrinal claim, that expresses what a community holds. Treat meaning as multi-layered: propositional truth for the believer who assents to it, existential or transformative meaning for the person who lives by it, communal identity for the worshipping body, and possibly symbolic or expressive meaning for the outsider or critic. Ask who is addressed: the committed believer, the seeker, the philosopher, the secular observer. A statement may be deeply meaningful to a confessing Christian yet opaque or unpersuasive to a philosopher demanding public argument. Build a reasoned case that distinguishes these audiences and justifies your judgement about where the meaning lies.

    How coherent the beliefs are, and how consistent they are with other beliefs in the belief system.

    This criterion asks you to assess two related but distinct qualities of Christian beliefs: internal coherence and consistency with the wider belief system. Coherence concerns whether the parts of a belief fit together without contradiction, for example whether claims about God's omnipotence and human free will can be held jointly. Consistency concerns whether a particular belief harmonises with other beliefs the system already holds, such as a doctrine of creation sitting alongside a doctrine of salvation. Separate the two: a belief can be internally coherent yet clash with neighbouring doctrines, or fit the system yet contain tension within itself. Identify the specific beliefs you are comparing, state the apparent conflict or harmony, and reason about whether the tension can be resolved. Conclude with a justified judgement about how coherent and consistent the beliefs are.

    The relevance of philosophical enquiry for religious faith, with particular reference to the debate about the nature of faith as ‘belief in’ or ‘belief that’.

    This topic asks how far philosophical reasoning serves or threatens Christian faith, focusing on the distinction between faith as 'belief that' and faith as 'belief in'. 'Belief that' is propositional: assenting to claims such as that God exists or that Jesus rose from the dead, so evidence and argument bear directly on it. 'Belief in' is relational: trusting and committing oneself to God, closer to fiducia than to bare assent. Philosophical enquiry tests propositional claims for consistency and evidence, which can purify or unsettle faith. A learner should be able to explain both senses, show how they interlock (trust usually presupposes some beliefs about the one trusted), and assess whether philosophical scrutiny strengthens, undermines or simply reframes religious faith.

    Your focus

    1. Explain at least two philosophical challenges to the classical concept of God.
    2. Evaluate a Christian response to those challenges.
    3. Reach and justify a conclusion about the coherence of the concept of God.
    Show all 33 objectives
    1. Explain a Christian understanding of the self and the afterlife.
    2. Evaluate a philosophical objection to that understanding.
    3. Justify a conclusion about the most defensible account of self and destiny.
    4. Explain how at least two Christian sources of wisdom and authority are used in philosophical argument.
    5. Assess the strengths and limits of appealing to those sources.
    6. Reach and justify a judgement about which sources carry most weight.
    7. Explain different types of religious experience and their role in Christian belief.
    8. Analyse philosophical objections to arguments from religious experience.
    9. Evaluate how far religious experience supports Christian belief in dialogue with philosophy.
    10. Explain the distinguishing features of scientific and religious discourses.
    11. Apply at least one model of relationship to a concrete issue.
    12. Evaluate the strengths and limits of a chosen model of relationship.
    13. Distinguish between exclusivist, inclusivist and pluralist Christian responses to other religions.
    14. Assess the strengths and difficulties of at least one such response.
    15. Reach and justify a judgement about the most defensible position.
    16. Explain the main philosophical issues raised by miracle claims.
    17. Evaluate arguments for and against the credibility of miracles.
    18. Assess the impact of the miracle debate on Christian belief past and present.
    19. Explain what it means for a belief to be based on or consistent with reason.
    20. Evaluate arguments for and against the reasonableness of Christian belief.
    21. Reach a reasoned judgement on how far the belief is reasonable.
    22. Explain what makes a statement of faith meaningful and to which audiences.
    23. Distinguish propositional, existential and communal senses of meaning.
    24. Reach and justify a judgement about the meaningfulness of a statement of faith.
    25. Distinguish coherence from consistency when assessing Christian beliefs.
    26. Explain how specific beliefs relate to others in the system.
    27. Reach and justify a judgement about the coherence and consistency of the beliefs.
    28. Explain the distinction between faith as 'belief that' and faith as 'belief in'.
    29. Describe how philosophical enquiry bears on Christian faith.
    30. Assess whether philosophical reasoning strengthens or challenges religious faith.

    2B Christianity - Section B: The dialogue between Christianity and philosophy exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies the divine attributes under discussion and explains why each generates a philosophical difficulty.
    • Explains a philosophical objection to the classical concept of God and shows precisely which attribute it targets.
    • Presents a Christian response and assesses whether it defends the classical concept or modifies it.
    • Reaches a sustained, justified judgement about whether the concept of God survives philosophical scrutiny.
    • Explains a Christian account of the self and shows how it grounds claims about death and the afterlife.
    • Presents a philosophical objection, such as materialism or the problem of eternal punishment, and identifies what it challenges.
    • Evaluates a Christian response and judges whether it withstands the objection.
    • Reaches a justified conclusion about the most defensible account of self, death and the afterlife.
    • Identifies specific sources of wisdom and authority within Christianity, such as scripture, tradition, reason and religious experience.
    • Explains how a named source is used to support or challenge a philosophical argument, giving a concrete example.
    • Assesses the strengths and limits of relying on a particular source when engaging philosophical claims.
    • Reaches a reasoned judgement about the relative authority of different sources and justifies it.
    • Defines religious experience with reference to recognised types, such as mystical, numinous or revelatory experience, and explains how Christians use it.
    • Explains a philosophical challenge to religious experience, for example doubts about verifiability or about the role of interpretation.
    • Weighs the evidential value of religious experience against objections and considers at least one Christian response.
    • Reaches a justified judgement about how far religious experience supports Christian belief in dialogue with philosophy.
    • Distinguishes scientific discourse from religious discourse by naming the methods, authorities and purposes characteristic of each.
    • Explains at least one model of relationship, such as conflict, independence or dialogue, and applies it to a specific issue.
    • Uses a concrete example, such as evolutionary biology alongside a doctrine of creation, to show how the two discourses interact.
    • Assesses whether the chosen model adequately captures the relationship or leaves tensions unresolved.
    • Supports claims about Christian positions with reference to the specified Christian thought studied in this section.
    • Defines exclusivism, inclusivism and pluralism accurately and distinguishes between them.
    • Explains the reasoning a Christian offers for holding a particular position on other religions' truth claims.
    • Assesses strengths and difficulties of at least one position, such as the challenge pluralism poses to Christian exclusivity.
    • Reaches a reasoned judgement about which position is most defensible and justifies it.
    • Defines a miracle with precision, distinguishing a violation of natural law from an event carrying religious significance, and uses the definition consistently.
    • Explains Hume's argument that testimony for miracles is always outweighed by the uniform experience of natural law, and evaluates whether the argument succeeds.
    • Assesses counter-arguments such as Swinburne's principles of testimony and credulity, weighing whether they rescue miracle claims from Hume's critique.
    • Traces the impact of the debate on Christian belief in the past, for example in apologetics or procedures for verifying miracles, with accurate historical framing.
    • Traces the impact on present-day Christian belief, showing how believers defend providence or interpret prayer in light of philosophical criticism.
    • Reaches a sustained judgement on how far the philosophical discussion supports or undermines religious belief, rather than merely listing views.
    • Distinguishes clearly between a belief being based on reason and a belief being consistent with reason, and applies both tests.
    • Explains rational support for the belief, for example natural theology or a cosmological argument, and assesses its strength.
    • Assesses challenges to reasonableness, such as the problem of evil or divine hiddenness, and weighs them fairly.
    • Examines the relationship between faith and reason, judging whether revelation can complement rather than contradict rational enquiry.
    • Reaches a sustained judgement on how far the belief is reasonable, acknowledging the force of the opposing case.
    • Distinguishes propositional meaning, existential meaning and communal identity when assessing a statement of faith.
    • Identifies specific audiences, such as committed believers, seekers, philosophers or secular critics, and explains why meaning differs for each.
    • Explains how a creed functions as shared identity for a worshipping community rather than only as a truth claim.
    • Weighs whether a statement of faith can carry meaning for someone who does not assent to its truth.
    • Reaches a justified judgement about the extent and limits of the statement's meaningfulness.
    • Distinguishes internal coherence from consistency with other beliefs in the system.
    • Identifies specific beliefs being compared and states the apparent tension or harmony between them.
    • Explains whether an apparent conflict can be resolved and how.
    • Weighs evidence for and against the coherence of the beliefs before judging.
    • Reaches a justified conclusion about how coherent and consistent the beliefs are.
    • Distinguishes 'belief that' as propositional assent from 'belief in' as personal trust and commitment.
    • Explains how philosophical argument bears on propositional beliefs about God, for example arguments for and against God's existence.
    • Shows that trust in God typically presupposes some beliefs about God, so the two senses interlock rather than compete.
    • Assesses whether philosophical enquiry strengthens religious faith by clarifying it, or weakens it by exposing unresolved objections.
    • Identifies the relevance of philosophical enquiry for faith, including its role in testing coherence and in articulating reasons.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Plan the argument around two or three attributes so the discussion stays focused and analytical.
    • 💡Name the philosopher or tradition behind each objection so the dialogue is explicit.
    • 💡Reserve time to state and justify your own conclusion rather than ending on a summary of views.
    • 💡Structure the answer around belief, objection and response so the dialogue is visible.
    • 💡Use precise terms such as dualism, materialism and resurrection to signal understanding.
    • 💡Keep the conclusion analytical, explaining why one account is stronger than another.
    • 💡Anchor each paragraph in one source and one philosophical claim it addresses.
    • 💡Use precise terms such as revelation, natural reason and magisterium correctly.
    • 💡Reserve time to state and justify a clear conclusion about authority.
    • 💡Use one clear example of a religious experience per paragraph to illustrate the argument.
    • 💡Separate the description of an experience from the philosophical assessment of it so the analysis is visible.
    • 💡End with an explicit judgement about the strength of experience as support for belief.
    • 💡Define what you mean by 'discourse' early so your analysis has a clear frame.
    • 💡Anchor each model of relationship in a named example rather than describing it abstractly.
    • 💡Reserve time to evaluate: state which model you find most persuasive and why.
    • 💡Link back to Christian thought explicitly rather than writing a general science-and-religion essay.
    • 💡Define each position precisely before evaluating it.
    • 💡Use a concrete example of a Christian response to a named other religion to ground the discussion.
    • 💡State a clear conclusion and show what evidence supports it.
    • 💡Anchor each philosophical issue to a named thinker or argument so the discussion stays precise.
    • 💡Keep the impact strand explicit: state what changed or persists in Christian belief, past and present.
    • 💡Build towards a clear judgement in the conclusion that answers how far belief is affected.
    • 💡Use technical terms such as natural law, testimony and credulity accurately and consistently.
    • 💡State explicitly which belief you are assessing so the judgement stays focused.
    • 💡Use the two-part definition as a structure: first test whether the belief is based on reason, then whether it is consistent with reason.
    • 💡Support each claim with a named argument or thinker to keep the evaluation precise.
    • 💡End with a clear judgement on how far, not simply whether, the belief is reasonable.
    • 💡Name the audience explicitly in each paragraph so the 'for whom' clause is answered, not just the 'how meaningful' clause.
    • 💡Use a concrete example of a statement of faith to anchor the discussion rather than arguing in the abstract.
    • 💡Signal your judgement clearly and support it with reasons rather than listing views.
    • 💡State the two beliefs you are comparing at the start of each paragraph so the comparison is explicit.
    • 💡Use the words 'coherent' and 'consistent' precisely and consistently throughout.
    • 💡End with a clear judgement that answers both parts of the criterion.
    • 💡Define both senses of faith precisely before applying them to Christian examples.
    • 💡Use a concrete case, such as trusting God in suffering, to show how belief that and belief in combine.
    • 💡Weigh the relevance of philosophical enquiry rather than merely describing arguments.
    Common Mistakes
    • Lists attributes without connecting them to any objection; tie each attribute to a specific philosophical challenge.
    • Treats the problem of evil as the only issue; address at least one further challenge such as the Euthyphro dilemma or divine foreknowledge.
    • Asserts a conclusion without argument; support the judgement with reasoning drawn from the views discussed.
    • Describes beliefs without engaging any philosophical objection; pair each belief with a critique.
    • Confuses soul-survival with bodily resurrection; distinguish the two accounts clearly.
    • Offers a conclusion that merely restates views; argue for the judgement with reasons.
    • Lists sources without explaining how any of them functions in philosophical argument; connect each source to a specific claim.
    • Treats all Christians as holding identical sources of authority; distinguish between traditions where relevant.
    • Asserts a conclusion without weighing evidence; support the judgement with reasoning about the sources.
    • Describes experiences without linking them to an argument about God's existence or Christian belief; connect each example to the claim it supports.
    • Treats all religious experiences as identical; distinguish types and note that they may carry different evidential weight.
    • Dismisses objections without engaging them; state the challenge fairly before offering a response.
    • Treats science and religion as automatically in conflict; recognise that conflict is one contested model among several.
    • Reduces religious discourse to literal factual claims alone; acknowledge its revelatory, ethical and existential dimensions.
    • Describes one discourse only and ignores the other; balance the analysis across both.
    • Asserts a thinker's view without explaining the reasoning behind it; show how the position is argued.
    • Confuses inclusivism with pluralism; state clearly that inclusivism retains Christ as the means of salvation while pluralism does not.
    • Describes other religions only in caricature; represent their truth claims fairly before assessing them.
    • Offers a conclusion without weighing the positions; justify the judgement with reasons.
    • Treats a miracle as simply a surprising event; distinguish carefully between a violation of natural law and an event given religious interpretation.
    • Summarises Hume without evaluating his argument; assess the strength of the reasoning and the replies to it.
    • Lists past and present impact separately without connecting them; show how earlier debates shaped later Christian responses.
    • Asserts that the discussion settles the question; reach a reasoned judgement that acknowledges the strength of opposing views.
    • Conflates being based on reason with being consistent with reason; treat them as two distinct tests and apply each.
    • Treats faith as automatically irrational; examine whether faith and reason can be complementary.
    • Describes arguments without evaluating them; assess how far each argument actually supports the belief.
    • Ignores the strongest counter-arguments; engage with the problem of evil or hiddenness before concluding.
    • Treats meaning as a single property that a statement either has or lacks; separate propositional, existential and communal senses.
    • Assumes a statement of faith means the same to every reader; specify the audience and explain the difference.
    • Offers description of a creed without evaluating its meaningfulness; move from description to reasoned assessment.
    • Uses coherence and consistency as interchangeable terms; define and apply each separately.
    • Asserts that beliefs conflict without naming the specific doctrines involved; identify the beliefs being compared.
    • Declares a belief coherent without considering objections; weigh counter-arguments before concluding.
    • Treats 'belief in' and 'belief that' as identical; distinguish propositional assent from relational trust.
    • Assumes philosophy must destroy faith; assess both strengthening and unsettling effects.
    • Ignores that trust presupposes some beliefs about the one trusted; show how the two senses connect.