Skip to topic
    ← Back to course topics

    2B Christianity - Section B: The dialogue between Christianity and ethics — AQA A-Level Religious Studies

    2B Christianity - Section B: The dialogue between Christianity and ethics explained

    2B Christianity - Section B: The dialogue between Christianity and ethics covers 8 specification points, including Christian responses to the following… and deontological, with reference to Kant..

    Read the full explanation

    Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.

    Christian responses to the following approaches to moral decision-making in the light of key Christian moral principles:

    This topic requires learners to evaluate how Christians respond to named approaches to moral decision-making, judged against key Christian moral principles. The approaches are those set out in the specification's ethics content, such as natural law, situation ethics and other specified methods; learners should identify each approach and its reasoning. Key Christian moral principles include love of God and neighbour, the authority of scripture and Church teaching, and the example of Jesus. A strong response states the approach, explains how a Christian might accept or reject it by reference to those principles, and weighs the strengths and weaknesses of the resulting position. Responses should reach a justified judgement rather than merely list views.

    deontological, with reference to Kant.

    This topic examines the deontological approach to ethics with reference to Kant, in dialogue with Christian ethics. Deontology judges actions by duty and rules rather than consequences. Kant grounds morality in the categorical imperative: act only on maxims you could will as universal law, and treat persons as ends, never merely as means. Morality is thus a matter of rational duty, not outcome. Christian ethics shares the emphasis on duty and absolute commands, such as loving God and neighbour, yet differs in grounding morality in God's will and in allowing a role for grace and human flourishing. A learner should explain Kant's key ideas, show where they converge with and diverge from Christian ethics, and assess the strengths and limits of a purely duty-based approach.

    teleological and consequential, with reference to Bentham.

    This fragment sits inside the dialogue between Christianity and ethics, where you classify an ethical theory by its structure and its standard of value. A teleological theory judges an act by the end or purpose it pursues, so the rightness of the act depends on the outcome aimed at rather than on the act's inner form. A consequential theory judges an act by its results. Bentham's utilitarianism is both: it is teleological because it directs action towards the greatest happiness, and consequential because it measures acts by the pleasure and pain they produce, using the hedonic calculus to weigh intensity, duration, certainty, propinquity, fecundity, purity and extent. In the dialogue, ask how far a Christian ethic of agape, which may value the act or the agent's intention, agrees with or challenges this outcome-centred reasoning.

    character based, with reference to virtue ethics.

    This fragment names one of the four ways Christian ethics can be classified in the dialogue between Christianity and ethics: character based, understood through virtue ethics. Virtue ethics asks what kind of person one should become rather than which rule to follow or which outcome to maximise. It centres on virtues such as love, humility, patience and courage, on the character of Christ as a model, and on practices that form those habits over time. A Christian virtue approach typically treats agape as the shaping disposition and sees moral growth as formation in a community. In a multiple-choice question, identify the option that links character and virtues to Christian living, and reject options that describe only rule-keeping or only calculating consequences.

    How far Christian ethics can be considered to be deontological, teleological, consequential, or character based.

    This question asks you to weigh how far Christian ethics fits four classifications. Deontological ethics judges acts by duty and rules, so divine commands and absolute prohibitions such as the prohibition of murder can be read this way. Teleological ethics judges by the end or purpose an act serves, so an ethics oriented to the kingdom of God or to union with God can be read this way. Consequential ethics judges by outcomes, so an ethics weighing the greatest love or the greatest good can be read this way. Character-based ethics, through virtue ethics, judges by the kind of person formed, so an ethics centred on virtues and on the example of Christ fits here. Argue how far each label captures Christian ethics, using evidence and reaching a judgement.

    Christian responses to: the issues of human life and death and issues of animal life and death prescribed for study; theft and lying; marriage; homosexuality and transgender issues; genetic engineering.

    This row asks you to know how Christian thought responds to a set of applied ethical issues, each tied to the prescribed study material. For human life and death, expect debates about the value and sanctity of life, abortion and euthanasia, and how different Christian traditions reason from scripture, natural law and conscience. For animal life and death, consider stewardship and dominion, whether animals may be used for food or research, and whether they share moral status. For theft and lying, weigh absolute prohibitions against situation-based reasoning and the role of love of neighbour. For marriage, cover its purposes and the churches' differing views on divorce and remarriage. For homosexuality and transgender issues, learn the range of Christian positions and the pastoral and ethical arguments.

    Christian responses to issues surrounding wealth, tolerance and freedom of religious expression.

    This row asks you to know how Christian thought responds to three linked issues. On wealth, learn the tension between the dangers of riches and the duty of stewardship and generosity, drawing on teaching about the poor and about contentment. On tolerance, consider how Christians balance conviction about truth with respect for those of other faiths and none, and how this connects to love of neighbour. On freedom of religious expression, examine arguments for the right to practise and proclaim faith alongside the state's interest in order and the rights of others. Expect questions that test whether you can match a Christian argument to the correct issue and recognise that different traditions weigh these values differently.

    Christian understandings of free will and moral responsibility, and the value of conscience in Christian moral decision-making. The impact of other ethical perspectives and ethical studies on Christian views about these issues, both past and present. This may include challenges to and support for Christian views; compatibility of Christian views with those of other ethical perspectives; the relative strengths and weaknesses of Christian perspectives and other ethical perspectives studied on these issues; the implications of criticisms of Christian ethical teaching for the religion as a whole and its sources of authority.

    This dialogue topic asks you to set Christian teaching on free will, moral responsibility and conscience against the other ethical perspectives you have studied, past and present. Begin by explaining the Christian position: many Christians hold that God gives humans genuine freedom, so that moral responsibility is real, and that conscience works as a God-given capacity for moral discernment, though reason, scripture and church teaching also shape decisions. Then bring in another perspective, such as a naturalistic or psychological account of conscience, or a secular autonomy-based ethic, and assess whether it challenges or supports the Christian view. Weigh compatibility, strengths and weaknesses on both sides, and consider what sustained criticism implies for Christian authority and its sources. Reach a reasoned judgement rather than listing views.

    Your focus

    1. Explain the reasoning of specified approaches to moral decision-making.
    2. Apply key Christian moral principles to assess those approaches.
    3. Evaluate Christian responses and reach a justified judgement.
    Show all 24 objectives
    1. Explain deontological ethics with reference to Kant.
    2. Describe how Kantian duty compares with Christian ethics.
    3. Assess the strengths and limits of a duty-based approach.
    4. Distinguish teleological from consequential reasoning.
    5. Explain why Bentham's utilitarianism counts as both teleological and consequential.
    6. Compare outcome-centred ethics with a Christian ethic such as agape.
    7. Identify character-based ethics as a virtue-centred classification of Christian ethics.
    8. Explain how virtues such as love and humility shape Christian character.
    9. Distinguish a virtue approach from deontological and consequentialist approaches.
    10. Explain the four classifications of ethical theory and apply each to Christian ethics.
    11. Assess how far Christian ethics can be considered deontological, teleological, consequential or character based.
    12. Reach and justify a reasoned judgement using relevant evidence.
    13. Identify the applied ethical issue named in a multiple-choice stem.
    14. Recognise Christian reasoning drawn from scripture, natural law, tradition and conscience.
    15. Distinguish between the positions of different Christian traditions on a named issue.
    16. Identify whether a stem concerns wealth, tolerance or freedom of religious expression.
    17. Recognise Christian reasoning about wealth, tolerance and religious freedom.
    18. Distinguish between Christian traditions that balance these values differently.
    19. Explain Christian understandings of free will, moral responsibility and conscience.
    20. Compare Christian views with other ethical perspectives studied, past and present.
    21. Evaluate the implications of criticism for Christian authority and reach a reasoned judgement.

    2B Christianity - Section B: The dialogue between Christianity and ethics exam tips

    Marking Points
    • Identifies the specified approach to moral decision-making and explains its core reasoning.
    • Explains how key Christian moral principles, such as love of God and neighbour, bear on that approach.
    • Presents Christian acceptance or rejection of the approach with supporting reasoning.
    • Weighs strengths and weaknesses of the Christian response to reach a justified judgement.
    • Explains deontology as judging actions by duty and rules rather than by consequences.
    • States Kant's categorical imperative, including the formula of universal law and the formula of humanity as ends.
    • Shows how Kant grounds morality in rational duty rather than in God's command or outcome.
    • Compares Kantian duty with Christian ethics, noting shared emphasis on absolute commands and differing grounding.
    • Assesses strengths and limits of a purely deontological approach, such as conflicts between duties.
    • Identifies a teleological theory as one that evaluates an act by the end or purpose it serves rather than by the act itself.
    • Identifies a consequential theory as one that evaluates an act by its results.
    • Explains that Bentham's utilitarianism is teleological because it aims at the greatest happiness of the greatest number.
    • Explains that Bentham's utilitarianism is consequential because it measures acts by the pleasure and pain they produce through the hedonic calculus.
    • Relates the outcome-centred structure of Bentham's ethics to a Christian ethic such as agape, noting where the two converge or conflict.
    • Identifies character-based ethics as concerned with the kind of person an agent becomes rather than with isolated acts.
    • Links virtue ethics to dispositions such as love, humility and patience formed through practice and community.
    • Recognises that a Christian virtue approach treats the character of Christ as a model for formation.
    • Distinguishes a character-based classification from purely deontological or consequentialist descriptions of Christian ethics.
    • Explains deontological features of Christian ethics, such as duty to divine commands and absolute moral prohibitions.
    • Explains teleological features, such as orientation of moral life towards a God-given purpose or end.
    • Explains consequential features, such as weighing outcomes in terms of love or the greatest good.
    • Explains character-based features through virtue ethics, such as formation of virtues and following the example of Christ.
    • Weighs the extent to which each classification captures Christian ethics and reaches a supported judgement.
    • Identifies the specific applied issue named in the question before selecting the relevant Christian argument.
    • Explains a Christian position using a recognised source of authority such as scripture, natural law, tradition or conscience.
    • Distinguishes between the views of different Christian traditions rather than presenting one uniform response.
    • Applies the reasoning to the precise issue asked about, such as abortion, animal research, theft, marriage, sexuality or genetic engineering.
    • Selects the option that matches both the issue and the Christian reasoning described in the stem.
    • Identifies which of the three issues, wealth, tolerance or freedom of religious expression, the stem addresses.
    • Explains a Christian argument using a recognised source such as scripture, church teaching or natural law.
    • Distinguishes between Christian traditions that emphasise different balances of conviction and tolerance.
    • Applies the reasoning to the specific issue, such as stewardship of wealth, respect for other beliefs or the right to express faith.
    • Selects the option that correctly matches the issue with the Christian reasoning described.
    • Explains a recognisably Christian account of free will and links it to moral responsibility, showing why the two are held together.
    • Analyses the role conscience plays in Christian moral decision-making and relates it to scripture, reason or church teaching rather than treating it in isolation.
    • Brings in at least one other ethical perspective studied on these issues and states clearly whether it challenges or supports the Christian view.
    • Assesses compatibility between the Christian view and the other perspective, identifying where they converge and where they genuinely conflict.
    • Weighs relative strengths and weaknesses of the Christian perspective and of the other perspective on the same issue.
    • Considers what criticisms of Christian ethical teaching imply for the religion as a whole and for its sources of authority.
    • Reaches a sustained, reasoned judgement that answers the question rather than merely surveying positions.
    Examiner Tips
    • 💡Name the specific approach and outline its method before assessing Christian responses.
    • 💡Anchor each judgement in a stated Christian moral principle rather than general opinion.
    • 💡Build a clear conclusion that weighs the responses you have presented.
    • 💡State the categorical imperative accurately before applying it to an example.
    • 💡Use a concrete moral case to show how duty and consequence give different verdicts.
    • 💡Weigh the strengths and weaknesses of Kantian deontology against Christian ethics.
    • 💡Read the stem for the key term (teleological, consequential or Bentham) before scanning the options, so you classify the theory correctly.
    • 💡Eliminate any option that defines the theory by duty or by the act's inner form, since those describe deontological reasoning.
    • 💡Check that the chosen option names the correct standard of value, such as the greatest happiness, rather than a religious command.
    • 💡Read all options before choosing, and eliminate any that describe only rules or only consequences.
    • 💡Ask which option names a disposition or model of character rather than an act or a result.
    • 💡Check that the chosen option fits the Christian context, for example formation in love and in the example of Christ.
    • 💡Define each of the four terms briefly before applying them, so your use of them is precise.
    • 💡Support each classification with a specific Christian example, such as a command, a purpose or a virtue.
    • 💡Reach an explicit judgement on how far Christian ethics can be considered each type, rather than listing features only.
    • 💡Read the stem carefully to identify which applied issue is being tested before looking at the options.
    • 💡Eliminate options that describe no Christian source of authority or reasoning.
    • 💡Check whether the option reflects a particular tradition and whether the stem asked for that tradition.
    • 💡Revise each issue with at least two contrasting Christian positions so you can recognise them in options.
    • 💡Identify the named issue in the stem before evaluating the options.
    • 💡Reject options that ignore the tension between competing Christian values.
    • 💡Look for the option that names a source of authority and applies it to the issue.
    • 💡Revise each issue with two contrasting Christian emphases so you can spot them.
    • 💡Plan your argument around the dialogue: Christian view, other perspective, compatibility, strengths and weaknesses, implications, judgement.
    • 💡Anchor each claim about a perspective in a named thinker or tradition you have studied so the comparison is precise.
    • 💡Reserve time to write a clear concluding judgement that weighs the evidence rather than restating the introduction.
    Common Mistakes
    • Describes the approach without linking it to Christian moral principles; connect each method to love, scripture or Church teaching.
    • Lists Christian views without evaluating them; weigh strengths and weaknesses and reach a judgement.
    • Treats all Christians as holding one view; acknowledge diversity of Christian response.
    • Confuses deontology with consequentialism; keep duty and rules central, not outcomes.
    • Treats Kant's ethics as identical to Christian ethics; distinguish rational duty from divine command.
    • Omits the formula of humanity; include treating persons as ends, never merely as means.
    • Confuses teleological with deontological; keep teleological for end-directed theories and deontological for duty-based ones.
    • Treats consequential and teleological as identical; distinguish the appeal to results from the appeal to purpose, even where one theory is both.
    • Attributes the hedonic calculus to a Christian ethic; keep it with Bentham's utilitarianism and compare it to Christian love separately.
    • Treats virtue ethics as a rulebook that supplies commands; correct this by explaining that it asks what kind of person to become.
    • Assumes character-based ethics ignores actions entirely; correct this by noting that actions express and shape settled dispositions.
    • Confuses virtue ethics with calculating the greatest good; correct this by separating formation of character from outcome-maximising reasoning.
    • Treats teleological and consequential as identical; correct this by distinguishing judgement by purpose or end from judgement by outcomes.
    • Asserts that Christian ethics is purely one type without weighing evidence; correct this by assessing how far each label applies.
    • Describes virtue ethics without linking it to Christian character and the example of Christ; correct this by making that link explicit.
    • Treats all Christians as holding one identical view; correct this by naming the differing traditions and their reasoning.
    • Confuses the human life issue with the animal life issue; check which category the question names before answering.
    • Offers a personal opinion instead of a Christian response; anchor the answer in a stated Christian source of authority.
    • Ignores the specific issue in the stem and gives a general ethical statement; match the reasoning to the named issue.
    • Treats wealth as simply condemned or simply approved; correct this by explaining the tension between danger and stewardship.
    • Confuses tolerance with indifference to truth; show how Christians hold conviction and respect together.
    • Mixes up freedom of religious expression with freedom from religion; keep the focus on the right to practise and proclaim faith.
    • Chooses an option with no Christian source of authority; require scripture, tradition or church teaching.
    • Describes conscience only as a feeling and omits its role in Christian decision-making; explain it as a God-given capacity shaped by reason, scripture and church teaching.
    • Lists ethical perspectives side by side without comparing them; state explicitly where each challenges or supports the Christian view.
    • Treats criticism of Christian ethics as having no consequence for authority; discuss what it implies for the religion and its sources of authority.
    • Ignores the past-and-present dimension; show how Christian thinking on these issues has developed and how modern perspectives engage it.