2D Islam - Section A: Expressions of religious identity — AQA A-Level Religious Studies
2D Islam - Section A: Expressions of religious identity explained
2D Islam - Section A: Expressions of religious identity covers 3 specification points, including The similarities and differences between Shi’a… and The concept of pillar and purpose of the five….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
The concept of Muslim: the similarities and differences between Shi’a and Sunni views about what it means to be a Muslim.
Being a Muslim rests on shared foundations that both Sunni and Shi'a affirm: belief in the one God, acceptance of Muhammad as the final prophet, and the Qur'an as revelation. The Shahadah expresses this confession of faith, and both traditions practise prayer, fasting, charity and pilgrimage, though forms and details differ. Differences cluster around authority and practice: Sunnis emphasise the caliphate and the consensus of the community with the Five Pillars, while Shi'a emphasise the Imamate, the authority of the Imams descended from Ali, and add distinctive practices and commemorations. A strong answer identifies a genuine similarity, a genuine difference, and explains what each reveals about Muslim identity rather than merely listing labels.
The Pillars of Islam: the concept of pillar and purpose of the five pillars of Islam; Salah: differences in Sunni and Shi’a practices; the importance of the outward actions of prayer and the underlying intentions and state of mind; the importance of daily and Jummah prayers; Hajj: developments in the practice of Hajj in the 20th century and the significance and importance of Hajj today.
The five pillars are the framework of Muslim religious life: Shahadah (declaration of faith), Salah (prayer), Zakah (almsgiving), Sawm (fasting in Ramadan) and Hajj (pilgrimage to Makkah). The image of a pillar conveys something that supports and holds up a building, so the pillars are understood as sustaining the whole structure of a Muslim's faith and practice rather than as optional extras. Salah is performed five times daily at set times, with ritual washing, set movements and recitation, and Friday Jummah prayer gathers the community at midday. Sunni and Shi'a practice differs in some details, for example Shi'a Muslims commonly combine certain prayers and may use a small clay tablet (turbah) in prostration, while both traditions share the core form.
The mosque: the changing role of the mosque in the community, with particular reference to the history and developing work of the London Central Mosque.
A mosque (masjid) is first a place of prayer, but its role in the community has changed and widened over time. Traditionally it has served as a place of worship, teaching and gathering, and many mosques also provide education, welfare support, funeral services and spaces for social events. The London Central Mosque in Regent's Park is a useful case study: it was established in the 20th century with support from the British government and Muslim communities, and it has developed a broad programme of religious, educational and community work, including interfaith engagement and services for a diverse Muslim population. Questions on this topic usually ask you to explain how the role of the mosque has changed and to use the London Central Mosque as a specific example, so learn the general pattern and then apply it to that case.
Your focus
- Identify the shared beliefs that define a Muslim for both Sunni and Shi'a traditions.
- Explain key differences between Sunni and Shi'a views of Muslim identity.
- Assess what these similarities and differences reveal about Muslim identity.
Show all 9 objectives
- Explain the concept of a pillar and the purpose of the five pillars of Islam.
- Compare Sunni and Shi'a practices of Salah and explain the relationship between outward actions and inner intention.
- Describe developments in Hajj in the 20th century and explain the significance of Hajj today.
- Explain the changing role of the mosque in the community.
- Describe the history and developing work of the London Central Mosque.
- Apply general knowledge of mosque functions to a specific case study.
2D Islam - Section A: Expressions of religious identity exam tips
Marking Points
- States a shared foundation of Muslim identity such as belief in one God, Muhammad as final prophet, or the Qur'an.
- Identifies the Shahadah as a confession shared by Sunni and Shi'a Muslims.
- Explains a Sunni emphasis such as the caliphate, community consensus or the Five Pillars.
- Explains a Shi'a emphasis such as the Imamate and the authority of the Imams descended from Ali.
- Connects a similarity or difference to what it shows about Muslim identity rather than listing labels.
- Identifies the five pillars as Shahadah, Salah, Zakah, Sawm and Hajj and explains that the pillar image conveys support and structure for the whole of religious life.
- Explains that the purpose of the pillars is to give a shared framework of belief and practice that shapes a Muslim's daily conduct and relationship with God.
- Distinguishes Sunni and Shi'a practice of Salah, for example differences in combining prayers or the use of a clay tablet in prostration, while noting the shared core form.
- Explains that the outward actions of prayer express obedience and discipline and that the niyyah and state of mind give those actions their religious meaning.
- Explains the importance of the five daily prayers as a regular discipline and of Jummah prayer as a weekly gathering of the community.
- Describes developments in Hajj during the 20th century, such as modern transport and large-scale crowd management, and explains the continuing significance of Hajj today.
- Explains that the mosque's primary role is as a place of prayer and worship and that this role has widened over time.
- Describes additional community functions of the mosque, such as education, welfare support, funeral services and social gathering.
- Explains how the role of the mosque has changed, for example through greater engagement with wider society and interfaith work.
- Uses the London Central Mosque as a specific example, referring to its history and its developing community work.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Balance the answer with at least one clear similarity and one clear difference.
- 💡Explain what each belief or practice reveals about Muslim identity, not just its name.
- 💡Use precise terms such as Shahadah, Imamate and caliphate to show accurate knowledge.
- 💡Read the question stem carefully to see whether it asks about the concept of pillar, a specific pillar, or the purpose of the five as a set.
- 💡When a question asks about differences, name the tradition and the specific practice rather than saying only that they differ.
- 💡Link outward action to inner intention explicitly, since questions often test the relationship between the two.
- 💡For Hajj questions, keep developments within the 20th century and connect them to the significance of Hajj today.
- 💡Anchor general statements about the mosque's role with a specific example from the London Central Mosque.
- 💡Use the phrase 'changing role' as a prompt to contrast earlier and current functions.
- 💡Keep factual claims about the London Central Mosque accurate and avoid inventing dates or details you are unsure of.
- 💡Structure answers so that the general point comes first and the specific example follows.
Common Mistakes
- Treats Sunni and Shi'a as entirely separate religions; correct this by stating their shared foundations.
- Lists differences without explaining their significance; link each to authority or practice.
- Confuses the Imamate with the caliphate; distinguish Shi'a Imam authority from Sunni caliphal leadership.
- Assumes all Muslims practise identically; note variation within each tradition.
- Lists the pillars without explaining the concept of a pillar or the purpose of the five; add the supporting image and the function of the framework.
- Treats Sunni and Shi'a prayer as entirely different; recognise the shared core and describe the specific differences accurately.
- Separates outward actions from inner intention and treats only one as important; explain how the niyyah and state of mind give the actions meaning.
- Describes Hajj only as a historical ritual; include 20th-century developments and its significance for Muslims today.
- Describes the mosque only as a building for prayer; include its wider community functions and how these have developed.
- Mentions the London Central Mosque without giving any detail about its history or work; supply specific, accurate points.
- Assumes all mosques have identical roles; recognise variation between communities while explaining the general pattern.