2D Islam - Section A: Islam and science — AQA A-Level Religious Studies
2D Islam - Section A: Islam and science explained
2D Islam - Section A: Islam and science covers 4 specification points, including Science’s emphasis on evidence and reason;… and How science has challenged Muslim belief and….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
How and why science has influenced Islam and how Islam has responded, with particular reference to: science’s emphasis on evidence and reason; specific scientific discoveries; science as a stimulus to Muslim ethical thinking.
This topic asks you to trace a two-way relationship. First, explain how and why science has influenced Islam: science stresses evidence and reason, so Muslim thinkers ask whether observation and rational argument can sit alongside revelation, and many argue that the Qur'an repeatedly calls believers to reflect on the natural world, making empirical enquiry a religious duty rather than a threat. Second, show how Islam has responded. Use specific scientific discoveries as concrete cases, for example cosmology describing an expanding universe or genetics explaining inherited variation, and assess how Muslims read them alongside scripture. Third, treat science as a stimulus to Muslim ethical thinking: biomedical advances such as IVF, genetic screening or organ transplantation raise questions about the sanctity of life, stewardship (khalifa) and divine will, prompting fresh ijtihad.
How science has challenged Muslim belief and different Muslim responses to Darwin’s theory of evolution and the Big Bang theory.
This topic asks you to explain the challenge science poses to Muslim belief and then to compare different Muslim responses to two named theories. Start with the challenge: Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection appears to explain the diversity of life without direct creation, and the Big Bang describes an origin of the universe that some read as confirming a creator and others as replacing divine action. Then set out a range of responses. Some Muslims accept evolution as compatible with the Qur'an, reading creation accounts symbolically and seeing God as the author of natural processes. Others reject it as contradicting scriptural accounts of Adam's creation. On the Big Bang, many see the expanding universe as harmonious with Qur'anic language about the heavens, while some stress that scientific description does not displace divine causation.
The importance of science in early Muslim thought: science as a duty required by the Qur’an. The belief that the Qur’an revealed what science later confirmed with reference to the work of Maurice Bucaille.
This topic examines why early Muslim thinkers treated the pursuit of science as a religious obligation rather than a secular extra. The Qur'an repeatedly directs believers to observe natural phenomena, and classical scholars read such verses as commands to investigate the created order, so astronomy, medicine and mathematics became acts of worship. A second strand is the claim, associated with Maurice Bucaille, that the Qur'an anticipated findings that science confirmed only centuries later, so scripture and reason agree. A multiple-choice question here tests whether you can distinguish the duty-to-investigate argument from the Bucaille concordist argument, and whether you can identify which claim each supports.
Different Muslim responses to ethical issues raised by science: genetic engineering.
This topic asks you to set out the range of Muslim ethical responses to genetic engineering, not a single verdict. Responses draw on principles such as the sanctity of life, stewardship of creation, the avoidance of harm, and the preservation of lineage. Some Muslims accept genetic engineering where it treats disease and reduces suffering, treating it as legitimate medical benefit. Others raise concerns about altering creation, unknown long-term harms, and questions of justice in access to treatment. A strong answer shows that these positions rest on different weightings of the same sources, and that the reasoning, not just the conclusion, is what earns credit.
Your focus
- Explain how and why science has influenced Islam with reference to evidence and reason.
- Analyse how Islam has responded to specific scientific discoveries.
- Evaluate how science stimulates Muslim ethical thinking and reach a supported judgement.
Show all 12 objectives
- Explain how science has challenged Muslim belief.
- Analyse different Muslim responses to Darwin's theory of evolution and the Big Bang theory.
- Evaluate how far these challenges can be reconciled with Muslim belief and reach a supported judgement.
- Explain why early Muslim thinkers regarded scientific enquiry as a duty.
- Distinguish the duty argument from Bucaille's confirmation argument.
- Identify the scholar associated with the claim that the Qur'an anticipated science.
- Describe different Muslim responses to genetic engineering.
- Explain the ethical principles underlying each response.
- Evaluate the competing responses using a specific example.
2D Islam - Section A: Islam and science exam tips
Marking Points
- Explains how science's emphasis on evidence and reason influences Muslim thought by showing that observation and rational argument are treated as compatible with, or supportive of, revelation.
- Uses a specific scientific discovery, such as an expanding universe or genetic inheritance, to show concretely how scientific findings enter Muslim discussion.
- Assesses how Islam has responded to scientific influence, distinguishing between acceptance, reinterpretation of scripture and cautious reservation.
- Explains how science acts as a stimulus to Muslim ethical thinking, using a biomedical or environmental example to show how new dilemmas prompt moral reasoning.
- Reaches a supported judgement about the extent to which science and Islam can be reconciled, weighing evidence rather than asserting a conclusion.
- Explains how science challenges Muslim belief, identifying the tension between natural explanation and belief in divine creation.
- Describes Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection and explains at least one Muslim response to it, such as acceptance through symbolic reading or rejection as contrary to scripture.
- Describes the Big Bang theory and explains at least one Muslim response, such as seeing it as harmonious with the Qur'an or as not displacing divine causation.
- Compares different Muslim responses, showing that Muslims disagree and giving reasons for each position.
- Reaches a supported judgement about how far the challenges can be reconciled with Muslim belief, weighing the evidence.
- Identifies that the Qur'an is held to command observation of nature, making scientific enquiry a religious duty.
- Distinguishes the duty argument from Bucaille's claim that the Qur'an prefigured later scientific findings.
- Recognises that early Muslim scholars integrated scientific study with religious learning rather than separating them.
- Selects the option that correctly attributes the concordist argument to Maurice Bucaille.
- Outlines at least two distinct Muslim responses to genetic engineering, such as acceptance for therapeutic benefit and caution about altering creation.
- Explains the principles underpinning each response, for example sanctity of life, stewardship, avoidance of harm or preservation of lineage.
- Applies these principles to a specific case such as gene therapy for inherited disease.
- Evaluates the strength of the competing responses rather than merely listing them.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Plan your answer around the three named references: evidence and reason, specific discoveries, and ethical stimulus.
- 💡Anchor each point in a named discovery or ethical issue so the analysis stays concrete.
- 💡Signal evaluation explicitly, for example by weighing acceptance against reservation before judging.
- 💡Keep terminology accurate, using terms such as khalifa and ijtihad only where you can explain them.
- 💡Structure your answer around the two named theories, treating each in turn.
- 💡For each theory, present more than one Muslim response so comparison is visible.
- 💡Use precise scientific language, for example natural selection and the expanding universe.
- 💡Make your evaluation explicit by weighing which responses are most persuasive and why.
- 💡Read the stem carefully to see whether it asks about the duty argument or the Bucaille argument.
- 💡Eliminate options that make the Qur'an a literal science manual, since the topic concerns confirmation not textbook content.
- 💡Check the named scholar in the option matches the claim being described.
- 💡Anchor each response in a named principle so the reasoning is visible.
- 💡Use a concrete example such as gene therapy to show how principles apply.
- 💡Weigh the responses against each other to reach a supported judgement.
Common Mistakes
- Treats science and Islam as simply opposed; recognise that the question asks how science has influenced Islam and how Islam has responded, which requires a two-way analysis.
- Lists discoveries without linking them to Muslim thought; connect each discovery to a specific Muslim response or ethical debate.
- Ignores the ethical-thinking clause; include at least one example of science prompting Muslim moral reasoning, such as a biomedical dilemma.
- Asserts a conclusion without weighing evidence; support the judgement with reasons drawn from the material discussed.
- Treats all Muslims as holding one view; show that responses differ and give reasons for the differences.
- Describes evolution or the Big Bang inaccurately; state each theory correctly before analysing responses.
- Mentions a theory without linking it to a specific Muslim response; connect each theory to at least one reasoned position.
- Offers a conclusion without weighing positions; support the judgement by comparing the strengths of the responses discussed.
- Treats science as purely secular in early Islam; correct this by noting the religious duty to investigate creation.
- Attributes the Qur'an-confirms-science argument to early jurists generally; correct this by linking it specifically to Bucaille.
- Confuses the duty to observe nature with a claim that the Qur'an is a science textbook; keep the two distinct.
- Presents a single uniform Muslim view; correct this by showing a genuine range of responses.
- States conclusions without the underlying principles; correct this by linking each view to a named ethical principle.
- Ignores the specific issue of genetic engineering and writes generally about science; keep the answer focused on genetic engineering.