2D Islam - Section A: Islam, gender and sexuality — AQA A-Level Religious Studies
2D Islam - Section A: Islam, gender and sexuality explained
2D Islam - Section A: Islam, gender and sexuality covers 4 specification points, including Encounter with western values and lifestyles… and The veil seen as a barrier to achievement in….
Read the full explanation
Open a point below for its explanation and revision guidance.
Historical and social factors that have influenced developments in Muslim thinking about these issues including: encounter with western values and lifestyles as part of the British Empire and through later immigration into Britain; the changing roles of men and women in society outside of religion; the rights given to women by secular governments.
This topic traces how Muslim thought on gender and sexuality has been shaped by historical and social pressures rather than by scripture alone. Three strands must be covered. First, encounter with western values and lifestyles, both through the experience of the British Empire and through later immigration into Britain, which brought Muslim communities into sustained contact with different family norms, legal expectations and public attitudes. Second, the changing roles of men and women in society outside religion, such as women's wider participation in education and paid employment, which prompted fresh reflection on family roles and authority. Third, the rights given to women by secular governments, for example statutory rights in marriage, divorce, inheritance and employment, which created debate about how far such provisions align with or diverge from religious teaching.
The veil seen as a barrier to achievement in Qasim Amin’s work in 1899 and other Muslim views on this issue.
This topic requires knowledge of Qasim Amin's 1899 work and the argument that the veil acts as a barrier to achievement, together with other Muslim views on the same issue. Learn Amin's position: writing in 1899, he presented the veil as an obstacle to women's advancement and to wider social progress, arguing that removing it would enable women to contribute to public life and education. Then learn contrasting and supporting Muslim views. Some thinkers defend the veil as a religious obligation and a source of dignity and protection, rejecting the claim that it blocks achievement. Others distinguish modest dress from seclusion, holding that covering need not prevent education or employment. A strong answer attributes the barrier argument to Amin's 1899 work, presents other Muslim views fairly, and compares them without caricature.
Debates about the role and status of women in Islam with particular reference to the interpretation of 4:34 and the views of Amina Wadud.
This debate turns on how Muslims read Qur'an 4:34, which addresses men as maintainers of women, speaks of righteous women as devoutly obedient, and includes a disputed phrase often rendered as 'strike' or 'beat' in some translations. Learners should show that interpretation is contested: some read the verse as establishing male responsibility and female protection within a patriarchal context, others stress its historical setting and argue that its ethical thrust is justice and mutual care. Amina Wadud, a contemporary Muslim scholar, reads the Qur'an through a gender-inclusive hermeneutic, arguing that the text's universal principles should be distinguished from its particular seventh-century applications and that women's full moral agency is affirmed.
Contemporary Muslim views about celibacy, marriage, homosexuality and transgender issues.
This topic surveys the range of contemporary Muslim positions on four linked issues. On celibacy, most Muslim thought treats marriage as the norm and generally discourages lifelong celibacy, though some value ascetic devotion. On marriage, Muslims broadly affirm it as a religious and social good while differing over polygyny, consent and divorce. On homosexuality, many traditional scholars regard same-sex acts as impermissible, while some contemporary Muslims argue for inclusion and reinterpret the relevant texts. On transgender issues, views range from acceptance of medical transition in some contexts to rejection on grounds of a perceived created order. A good answer recognises that these are contested, that Muslims cite Qur'an, hadith, reason and context differently, and that no single view represents all Muslims.
Your focus
- Outline the three historical and social factors named in the statement.
- Explain how each factor influenced developments in Muslim thinking.
- Distinguish the colonial encounter from later immigration into Britain.
Show all 12 objectives
- State Qasim Amin's 1899 view of the veil as a barrier to achievement.
- Describe other Muslim views on the veil.
- Compare Amin's position with alternative Muslim perspectives.
- Explain the content of Qur'an 4:34 and why its interpretation is contested.
- Outline and compare at least two readings of 4:34, including Amina Wadud's approach.
- Evaluate which interpretation is more persuasive with reasoned argument.
- Distinguish contemporary Muslim views on celibacy, marriage, homosexuality and transgender issues.
- Explain the reasoning Muslims give for differing positions.
- Recognise that these issues are contested and that no single view represents all Muslims.
2D Islam - Section A: Islam, gender and sexuality exam tips
Marking Points
- Identifies encounter with western values and lifestyles through the British Empire as a historical factor shaping Muslim thinking.
- Explains later immigration into Britain as a distinct social factor that continued that encounter.
- Describes the changing roles of men and women in society outside religion as an influence on Muslim reflection.
- Explains how rights given to women by secular governments prompted debate among Muslim thinkers.
- Distinguishes the colonial-era factor from the post-immigration factor rather than merging them.
- Attributes the view of the veil as a barrier to achievement to Qasim Amin's work of 1899.
- Explains Amin's reasoning that the veil obstructed women's advancement and social progress.
- Presents at least one other Muslim view that defends the veil as a religious obligation or source of dignity.
- Distinguishes modest dress from seclusion when presenting alternative Muslim positions.
- Compares Amin's position with other Muslim views rather than presenting only one side.
- Explains the content of Qur'an 4:34, identifying its address to men as maintainers and its description of righteous women, and shows awareness that the verse is interpreted rather than read in a single fixed way.
- Outlines at least two contrasting interpretations of 4:34, such as a patriarchal reading stressing male authority and a contextual reading stressing justice and mutual responsibility, and gives the reasoning behind each.
- Explains Amina Wadud's hermeneutical approach, including her argument that universal Qur'anic principles should be distinguished from particular historical applications and that women's moral agency is affirmed.
- Compares the interpretations, identifying where they agree and where they diverge, and evaluates which reading is more persuasive with reasons drawn from text and ethics.
- Reaches a justified judgement about the role and status of women in Islam, acknowledging that the debate is ongoing and that Muslims hold a range of positions.
- Identifies that Muslim views on celibacy generally favour marriage as the norm while acknowledging minority ascetic traditions.
- Recognises that Muslim positions on marriage affirm it as a religious good while differing over polygyny, consent and divorce.
- Distinguishes traditional scholarly rejection of same-sex acts from contemporary arguments for inclusion and reinterpretation.
- Shows awareness that transgender issues attract a range of Muslim responses, from acceptance of medical transition to rejection, and that these rest on differing readings of texts and created order.
- Acknowledges that these are contested issues and that no single view represents all Muslims.
Examiner Tips
- 💡Name each of the three factors explicitly so the examiner can see full coverage.
- 💡Use a concrete example, such as statutory rights in marriage or women's employment, to anchor each factor.
- 💡Link each factor to a specific effect on Muslim thinking rather than listing factors alone.
- 💡Name Qasim Amin and the year 1899 explicitly when presenting the barrier argument.
- 💡Give at least one clearly attributed alternative Muslim view to satisfy the 'other views' clause.
- 💡Use comparison language to show how the positions differ rather than listing them separately.
- 💡Anchor every interpretive claim to specific wording or features of 4:34 so the debate is textual rather than abstract.
- 💡Present at least two readings before evaluating, so the comparison is visible to the examiner.
- 💡Use evaluative language such as 'more persuasive because' to signal judgement rather than description.
- 💡Read the question stem carefully to identify which of the four issues is being tested.
- 💡Eliminate options that present a single view as universal when the topic is contested.
- 💡Check that the chosen option reflects the reasoning Muslims actually give, not a stereotype.
Common Mistakes
- Treats the British Empire and later immigration as one undifferentiated factor; separate the colonial encounter from post-immigration experience in Britain.
- Assumes secular legal rights are simply rejected by all Muslim thinkers; show that responses range from acceptance to reinterpretation to resistance.
- Reduces the topic to scripture alone; include the social and historical factors named in the statement.
- Confuses changing gender roles outside religion with changes within religious practice; keep the two distinct.
- Attributes the barrier argument to all Muslim thinkers; restrict it to Qasim Amin's 1899 work and identify others separately.
- Treats the veil and seclusion as identical; distinguish modest dress from the seclusion of women.
- Presents other Muslim views as uniform; show that they vary in defending or qualifying the veil.
- Omits the date 1899; anchor Amin's argument to his 1899 work.
- Treats 4:34 as having one undisputed meaning; correct this by showing that translation and interpretation are contested and that scholars read the verse differently.
- Describes Wadud's view only in slogan form without explaining her hermeneutical reasoning; correct this by outlining how she distinguishes universal principles from particular applications.
- Asserts a personal opinion without supporting argument; correct this by grounding evaluation in textual and ethical reasoning.
- Presents one Muslim view as the only Muslim view; correct this by showing that positions are contested and that scholars differ.
- Confuses celibacy with marriage avoidance in general; correct this by distinguishing lifelong abstention from delayed or chosen marriage.
- Treats homosexuality and transgender issues as identical; correct this by distinguishing the debates and the texts each invokes.